Convo with Noah:
Noah: "Mom! Today was Josh's birthday."
Me: "Cool. What did he bring in?"
Noah: "Nothing. He brought nothing."
Me: "Oh...I just thought that since you mentioned that today was Josh's birthday that maybe he brought treats in to camp."
Noah: "He did. But, you didn't ask me if he brought in treats."
Me: (Sigh) "You are right. I guess I should have been more specific."